Discussion about this post

User's avatar
C Boyle's avatar

I’m reminded of an incident many years ago when my husband and I were working on his car trying to get a belt off. I have a Master’s in Engineering and my husband was working on his Ph.D in physics. We were trying to figure out how to get this stubborn belt off when our neighbor wandered up, he worked on an oil rig as a mechanic and happened to be home. He watched us for a couple of minutes and then said, “well, why don’t you just cut it off?”. I said, “Because we’re idiots.”. I never forgot that moment, especially when I’m tempted to think I’m the expert! Good article!

Expand full comment
GraceMT's avatar

I watched the longer version of the IQ video. The Yale graduate and the Marine had the same IQ test score (131).

But there were clues to their respective backgrounds that make this result impressive. The Yale graduate was uninterested in going to college; her parents insisted, so she applied to *one* college. She says she was surprised she got into Yale but would her parents have capitulated if her admission was impossible? I’m speculating, but I’m pretty sure she went to private schools and got any tutoring she needed, especially for doing well on SAT/ACT tests. (This video predates college waivers of test scores).

The Marine went straight to boot camp after graduating high school. That’s consistent with a bright kid who probably went to a decent high school but didn’t have the financial means to pay for college outright. He decided to opt into military service now and subsidised college later. However, it’s unlikely he had extensive test prep or private schools who “taught” him how to maximise test scores.

How is this relevant to news organisations? Matt Taibbi often tells how his dad was in journalism at a time when most reporters were working class, like the Marine. They often started at local papers, then progressed to major cities. The most talented ended up at NYT, etc, after a lifetime of rubbing shoulders with ordinary people. Today, most journalists at NYT have backgrounds similar to the Yale graduate. Somehow we bought into the idea that the upper classes were in a better position to evaluate information. And here we are.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts